This is probably too late, but if you have an iphone...
I'd recommend Etcetera, Etcetera on 44th between 8th and 9th (closer to 9th)...great northern Italian. Tell them Robert Westfield sent you and you'll get a free dessert or some little perq. Also, Angus McIndoe on 44th between Times Square and 8th...great post-theater hangout with theater folk. Next to "Gypsy" across from "Phantom of the Opera."